For the Girls vs. What Do You Meme? Which Party Game?
By Relatable | Published: 2026-10-26
Category: Comparisons
Compare For the Girls and What Do You Meme? to find the best adult party game for your next girls' night or game night.
Quick Answer
Choose For the Girls if you want a girls-only party game built around sleepover-style confessions and inside jokes. Choose What Do You Meme? if you need a flexible, meme-based party game that works for mixed groups and keeps getting fresh with expansion packs.
The Core Difference: Audience vs. Flexibility
For the Girls is designed specifically for a girls' night audience. Its prompts lean into shared experiences, embarrassing secrets, and playful judgments about friends—think pranking an ex or admitting to cringe fads. That focus makes it a great icebreaker for bachelorettes, sorority gatherings, or birthdays where everyone knows each other.
What Do You Meme? is a broader party game that works for any group, not just one gender. The gameplay revolves around matching caption cards to photo cards, which means the humor depends on your group's meme literacy and timing. It's a safer bet for mixed crowds, office parties, or game nights where you want everyone involved.
Trade-Off: Shared Jokes vs. Fresh Content
For the Girls shines when your group already shares a history. The prompts are personal and can lead to hilarious revelations, but they may fall flat if the players aren't close or if the group includes someone who doesn't identify with the 'girls' experience.
What Do You Meme? relies on current meme references, which can age quickly. However, the Fresh Memes #1 Expansion Pack adds 90 new caption cards and 25 new photo cards, so you can keep the game relevant. That's a real advantage if you play often or want to tailor the humor to your group's taste.
How to Choose
- If you want a girls-only night: Pick For the Girls. Its prompts are built around female friendships, sleepover nostalgia, and personal confessions. It works best with a group that knows each other well and is ready to share. Check that your group is comfortable with personal questions before you start.
- If you need a flexible party game: Choose What Do You Meme? It works for mixed groups, and the photo-card format lets everyone participate regardless of gender. You can also add expansion packs like Fresh Memes #1 to keep it new. Consider buying an expansion pack if you think the base game will get old fast.
- If you want to combine both: Use For the Girls for a bachelorette or girls' night, and keep What Do You Meme? for larger or mixed gatherings. Both are affordable, so you can own both without breaking the bank. Having both covers every party scenario.
Product Facts
- For the Girls™ - Ultimate Girl's Night Card Game: For the Girls delivers hilarious, grown-up spins on classic sleepover vibes, with prompts about pranking an ex, embarrassing secrets, cringe fads, and more. This makes it ideal for close friends who want to laugh at shared experiences and learn something new about each other.
For the Girls™ - Ultimate Girl's Night Card Game - What Do You Meme?® Fresh Memes #1 Expansion Pack: The What Do You Meme? Fresh Memes #1 Expansion Pack includes 90 new caption cards and 25 new photo cards, designed for ages 17+ due to mature language. This keeps the base game fresh and lets you customize the humor, which is perfect for groups that play regularly or want the latest meme references.
What Do You Meme?® Fresh Memes #1 Expansion Pack
Which Should You Get?
Best for
- Girls' nights, bachelorettes, and birthdays where the group is all female and close
- Players who enjoy personal, confession-style humor and sleepover vibes
Not for
- Mixed-gender groups or parties where you need a game that everyone can enjoy equally
- Players who prefer meme-based humor and want the ability to refresh the game with expansion packs
