New Phone Who Dis vs Incohearent: Which 17+ Game Wins?
By Relatable | Published: 2026-10-16
Category: Comparisons
New Phone, Who Dis? rewards quick, funny text replies; Incohearent rewards decoding gibberish phrases. Compare the two 17+ party games to pick the right one for your group.
Quick answer
Choose New Phone, Who Dis? if your group loves writing-style humor and fast, laugh-out-loud rounds where the funniest reply wins. Choose Incohearent if your group prefers a phrase guessing game that turns slurred-sounding gibberish into a race to decode. Both are 17+ adult party games, but they reward different skills: quick wit versus quick ears.
How the two games actually play
New Phone, Who Dis? is a text message party game. One player acts as the Judge and reads an inbox card aloud. Everyone else picks the funniest reply card from their hand, and the Judge chooses a favorite. The winner keeps the round. It moves fast, needs at least 3 players, and works best when people are comfortable being a little unfiltered.
Incohearent is a phrase guessing game. Players read cards filled with gibberish that sounds like a real phrase when spoken aloud, then race to decode it. The Fresh Phrases Expansion Pack adds 180 new gibberish cards to the base game, so it only works if you already own Incohearent. It is also 17+ for mature language and references.
What changes with each game's pace and setup
New Phone, Who Dis? needs no expansion to start playing, and the second edition includes 100% new content compared with the first. The Judge role rotates naturally, so one person can sit out a round without stalling the game. Rounds are short, which makes it easy to stop or swap players mid-session.
Incohearent is more of a shared puzzle. Everyone can shout guesses at the same time, so it can feel louder and more chaotic than a judged card game. The Fresh Phrases expansion is a small add-on rather than a standalone game, so factor in the base set if you are buying from scratch.
What to consider before you pick
If your group already owns What Do You Meme? or similar judge-and-pick games, New Phone, Who Dis? will feel familiar but still fresh because of the text-message format. If your group prefers cooperative shouting and word puzzles, Incohearent is the better fit. Neither game is designed for players under 17, and neither works well with a group that dislikes mature language.
Trade-offs: New Phone, Who Dis? vs Incohearent
- Skill rewarded: New Phone, Who Dis? rewards writing-style humor and reading the room; Incohearent rewards listening and word-decoding speed. Pick the game that matches your group's strongest party skill.
- Setup and player count: New Phone, Who Dis? plays with 3+ players out of the box; Incohearent Fresh Phrases requires the base game and works best when everyone can shout guesses at once. If you want zero extra purchases, choose New Phone, Who Dis?.
- Content refresh: New Phone, Who Dis? second edition is 100% new content; Incohearent Fresh Phrases adds 180 cards to an existing set. Buy New Phone, Who Dis? for a full new game; buy Fresh Phrases to extend a game you already own.
Key facts from the catalog
- New Phone, Who Dis?™ - Funniest Reply Wins: New Phone, Who Dis? is a 3+ player game where players match a funniest reply card to the Judge's inbox card; the Judge's favorite wins the round. It is a low-setup, fast-turn game that works for small groups of three or more and does not require expansions to play.
- Incohearent™ Fresh Phrases Expansion Pack: Incohearent Fresh Phrases Expansion Pack adds 180 new gibberish cards to Incohearent and is designed for ages 17+. This is an expansion, not a standalone game, so you need the base Incohearent set to use it; it refreshes a phrase guessing game your group already likes.
Which game fits your group?
Best for
- Groups of 3 or more who enjoy judge-and-pick card games and fast, funny text-reply humor
- Players who want a complete 17+ party game without needing an expansion
Not for
- Groups who prefer cooperative word puzzles or already own Incohearent and want more of it
- Players under 17 or anyone uncomfortable with mature language and references
