What Do You Meme? vs. Other Meme Games: Which is the Funniest?

Quick answer

For the most universally funny meme game, What Do You Meme? is a solid choice because it taps into internet culture and offers expansion packs like the Trisha Paytas pack. However, if your group loves writing their own comparisons, Like I Like My might generate more personalized laughs. The funniest game depends on your group's humor and how much they enjoy creating their own captions.

Meme-based party games have exploded in popularity, turning internet humor into a competitive social activity. But with so many options, it's hard to know which one will have your group in stitches. We're comparing What Do You Meme? with other meme-style card games to help you decide.

While all these games share a love for humor, they differ in how they deliver it: some rely on pre-printed memes, others on player creativity. We'll break down the tradeoffs so you can pick the funniest game for your next party.

How Meme Games Differ

The core of a meme game is creating funny combinations, but the source of humor varies. What Do You Meme? uses a central deck of image cards and a hand of caption cards; players compete to choose the funniest caption for a given image, mimicking the classic Cards Against Humanity format but with visual memes. This structure works well because the images are curated, and the captions are pre-written, leading to unexpected and often hilarious juxtapositions.

In contrast, Like I Like My takes a different approach: it gives you 'Tame Cards' and 'Wild Cards' and asks you to write your own response that connects the two. This game relies heavily on the players' wit and creativity, making it more unpredictable. The humor is personal and tailored to your group's inside jokes, but it can fall flat if players are shy or not quick with words.

• Consider your group's preference for structured humor vs. open-ended creativity.

Player Count and Group Dynamics

Most meme card games are designed for small to medium groups. What Do You Meme? typically accommodates 3-20 players, making it flexible for both intimate gatherings and larger parties. The judge role rotates each round, so everyone gets a chance to be in the spotlight.

Like I Like My is also group-friendly, but because it requires writing responses, it may work better with smaller groups where everyone feels comfortable sharing. Larger groups might become chaotic, and quieter players may be overshadowed. For a big party, a game with more structured turns might be easier to manage.

• Think about how many players you'll typically have and whether your group is comfortable with improv-style humor.

Replayability and Expansion Potential

One of the key advantages of What Do You Meme? is its ecosystem of expansion packs. For example, the Trisha Paytas Expansion Pack adds 15 Image Cards and 10 Caption Cards that capture the star's most viral moments, giving a fresh spin for fans. This means the base game can stay funny for longer as you mix and match expansions.

Like I Like My, on the other hand, is a standalone game. Its replayability depends on the creativity of your group. Since the responses are player-generated, the same cards can yield different results each time, especially with a new group. However, some players might find the novelty wears off after several rounds if the same jokes recur.

• If you love collecting expansions and having variety, What Do You Meme? offers more long-term value.

Tradeoffs to Consider

• Pre-written vs. player-written humor: What Do You Meme? provides curated captions that are consistently funny but can feel less personal. Like I Like My relies on your group's creativity, which can be hilarious but also hit-or-miss. Choose What Do You Meme? for guaranteed laughs; choose Like I Like My for inside jokes.
• Expansion ecosystem: What Do You Meme? has many expansion packs, like the Trisha Paytas pack, which keeps the game fresh. Like I Like My is standalone, so its longevity depends on your group's creativity. If you like variety, What Do You Meme? offers more long-term value.
• Group size and comfort: What Do You Meme? works well with larger groups and shy players because the captions are provided. Like I Like My requires everyone to write responses, which may be intimidating for some. For mixed comfort levels, What Do You Meme? is safer.

Product Facts

• What Do You Meme? Trisha Paytas Expansion Pack: This limited edition pack captures Trisha's most viral moments in hilarious, meme-able cards. It includes 15 Image Cards pulled from her social media and 10 Caption Cards. If you're a fan of Trisha Paytas or want fresh content for your What Do You Meme? game, this expansion adds a personal and current touch that the base game may lack.
• Like I Like My – The Adult Card Game Of Comparing Two Very Different Things: Based on the iconic joke and viral trend, this game has you comparing totally normal Tame Cards with outrageously spicy Wild Cards—and competing to write the funniest response that makes sense for both. The funniest response wins! This game stands out because it puts the humor in your hands. If your group loves improv and clever writing, this format can generate more personalized and memorable laughs.

Which Game Fits Your Group?

Best for

• Groups that love internet culture and want a game with established memes and expansion packs.
• Parties with a wide range of humor preferences where pre-written captions ensure consistent laughs.

Not for

• Groups that prefer creating their own humor and thrive on improvisation.
• Small, intimate gatherings where you want the game to feel more personalized and inside-joke-driven.

Ultimately, the funniest meme game is the one that matches your group's style. What Do You Meme? offers a reliable, curated experience with expansion potential, while Like I Like My delivers a more creative and personal challenge. Consider the tradeoffs above and pick the one that will have your friends quoting lines for days.